In my World Views class the past two weeks we have been studying Intelligent Design. Last week and yesterday we watched the recently released movie, Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed, with Ben Stein. It was actually really good.
The overall point of the movie is to prove that there is validity to the Intelligent Design claims. Stein, who is Jew, explores the many facets of the “battle” between the Intelligent Design movement and opposing views, especially the evolutionary theory. Stein works to bring to light the fact that the opposing views are hostile towards those who hold to Intelligent Design (ID), and that, for the most part, discussion of its ideas has been ignored and pushed out of classrooms and academia.
The “battle” is a lot bigger than I thought, and this video is very eye-opening. It’s true, it is a one-sided view of the argument; Stein holds to ID and promotes it. Critics could claim that it is biased. And it is. But, there has to be bias in presenting the truth, and that is how Stein has come about it. He examines the other arguments, but does not give them any foothold in taking control of the argument. ID is clearly the victor. The opponents are shown primarily in their “worst” lights. A question that should be asked is, “How helpful is it for Stein to make fun of and not listen to the ideas of these people, while blaming them for doing the very same thing?” It comes across in rather a bad light because of that, and the approach ends up as not very convincing, especially for someone opposed to the view. But, on the whole, the information brought forth is very valuable, especially for those who are open to learning and seeking the truth.
When I was done watching, I could not help but be challenged. As I was walking back to my room, I stared up at the sky, and at creation all around me, and worshiped God for it. I believe in Intelligent Design. I believe that there is ONE Intelligent Designer: God. But it was good for me to reaffirm that and also to reaffirm why I believe that. The evidence is clearly proof of God’s hand on the world.
There is much at stake in believing these things. At one point, an interviewee openly mocks Creationists, saying that “they’re the real idiots,” in reference to belief in the ark and the survival of creation through that. Are we strong enough in our faith to take such scorn? It is definitely time that we as Christians reaffirm and proclaim what we believe. Such a foundational part of the Christian World View should not be taken lightly, or sort of “skipped” in our attempts to present the Gospel. This Intelligent Designer is at the very center of what we believe, and should therefore be the center of everything we talk about, and of the way that we live our lives.
It is interesting to watch the conversation Stein has with evolutionist/atheist Richard Dawkins. Dawkins is speaking about how evolution explains everything. Stein asks the simple question, “how did life begin?” Dawkins admits that he has no idea. He suggests the possibility of highly developed intelligent creatures from another planet having come to earth very long ago, and created what we see, explaining the design that is in the world. Stein responds by saying he had no idea that Dawkins believed in Intelligent Design! Ultimately, when it comes down to it, Dawkins confesses that evolution has no explanation for the origin of life. He utterly rejects any notion of the Hebrew God of the Bible, and opts for the extraterrestrial creatures. An arbitrary argument at best, his comeback is weak, and the point is made that perhaps evolution is not the best answer after all.
The extreme of rejecting the Intelligent Design explanation results in the haunting reality of absolute futility. The movie very vividly portrays this with one man’s testimony of having come from believing in ID to ultimately rejecting it. Dr. William Provine passionately declares what he now feels: no hope, no God, no life after death, and no human free will. He said,
It starts by giving up an active deity, then it gives up the hope that is in your life after death. When you give those two up, the rest follows fairly easily. You give up the hope that there is an imminent morality. And finally, there’s no human free will. If you believe in evolution, you can’t hope that there be any free will. There’s no hope whatsoever of there being any deep meaning in human life. We live, we die, and we’re gone. We’re absolutely gone when we die.
Let’s suppose my [brain] tumor comes back, as it almost certainly will. Well, I’m not going to sit around like my older brother did last year as he was dying of ALS, Lou Gehrig’s disease. He wanted desperately to die, but we couldn’t help him die. I don’t want to die like that. I want to shoot myself in the head long before then. I’m going to do something different.
I don’t feel one bit bad about holding the views that I do. There’s not anything in the views I hold that makes me, “Oh, I wish I had free will,” or, “Oh, I wish there was a God.” I don’t EVER, EVER, wish that.
Those words are haunting. “We live, we die, and we’re gone.” That’s it. There is no meaning to life. What a sad place to be! That is the other extreme of this debate, and it is such a tragic place to be. We need to press for the truth to be known because of that. Because people like that are living lives of absolute meaninglessness. Because people like that are perfectly willing to die and go completely out of existence. Because people like that have absolutely no hope. I hope this is as sobering to you as it was to me.
So, yes, the movie is biased. It is one-sided. But it is so for the purpose of showing that the ideas of evolution are dominating academia, and the Intelligent Design is being pushed out of scope completely. It’s not only not fair in a purely scientific aspect, in that every view should be able to have equal validity until proven false, but it is a dangerous position. Expelled is a call to people of every place and status to examine these things. There is a battle on. And for Christians, what is at stake is the truth about everything we believe and trust and love and hope for. Can we remain silent on this issue?